Direct Indexing vs Managed Funds: Understanding the Difference for Australian Investors

Direct indexing in Australia gives you something traditional index funds don’t always provide: more control over the individual investments you own. You’re investing in an index, but you own the underlying securities directly. From there, you can customise those holdings by removing investments you don’t want.

 

In this sense, direct indexing works through a Separately Managed Account, but it gives you the added flexibility to personalise the securities held in your portfolio. You can still follow an index (such as the ASX 200) but retain the ability to customise those holdings according to the options available through your provider.

 

How is it different from a managed fund?

 

When you choose a managed fund, your money is pooled with money from other investors and a professional fund manager decides which investments the fund should buy and sell, with the goal of outperforming a particular benchmark.

 

This difference in management can also affect costs. Active fund managers regularly research investments and make decisions about what to buy and hold or sell, so managed funds can come with higher management fees than passive index-based investments.

 

How do you choose?

 

Aside from the amount you're investing, the two other main things to consider are (1) your preferred level of control and (2) how much customisation you want.

 

A traditional index simply tracks a particular index and generally follows its allocation. It's passive: there's no fund manager regularly deciding which securities to buy or sell, and as a result, its performance will largely reflect the performance of the securities that make up that index.

 

Managed funds could potentially outperform the benchmark if the fund management team chooses the right mix of holdings. But of course, performance is not guaranteed. Keep that in mind.

 

Direct indexing in Australia lands somewhere between. Like an index fund, it can track an index-based strategy. But because you directly own the underlying securities, you can have more flexibility to personalise your portfolio instead of accepting every holding in the index.

 

Make direct indexing work for you

 

At Nucleus Direct Indexing, we make it easier to personalise your superannuation and investment portfolios with our award-winning direct indexing solution.

 

Interested in seeing how direct indexing in Australia could fit into your investment strategy? Contact our team to learn more.

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is AI Investment Good Right Now? What Australian Investors Need to Know in 2026

Wealth Management VS Financial Planning: What Investors Need to Know

Wealth Management Platforms and the Changing Expectations of Australian Investors